The American music magazine Rolling Stone has made a fool of themselves (again). The magazine has presented a list of the "Top 50 Bands of All Time". The ignorant masses cheer. For example the site howtofeelgood.net (health and wellness page for those who want to keep fit and feel good) wrote: "This prestigious ranking highlights the most influential and celebrated groups in music history, honoring their lasting impact and contributions to the industry." In fact, the list is just ridiculous. I mean, placing U2 (no.3), Oasis (no.8), The Strokes (no.22), Guns N Roses (no.28) and Stone Roses (no.34) makes no sense. Halfway through, the editors seems to have become aware of that there were no black artists on the list and took affirmative action. Sly Stone and Public Enemy were included. I'm not the only one who have objections. In fact, the internet is filled with concerned people crossing over or replacing names. I haven't gone that far. Instead, I have rearranged the list in the correct order (my own list would have ended after no. 30). Finally, I have measured the similarity. Pearson correlation coefficient (rho) is a statistical method that measures the similarity or correlation between two data objects by comparing their attributes and calculating a score ranging from -1 to +1. A high score indicates high similarity, while a score near zero indicates no correlation. Pearson rho in this case is 0.18. And the conclusion? Do it over, do it right.
Disclaimer: Black Sabbath (first six albums), Deep Purple (third to ninth album), AC/DC (first three albums).
|
No |
Rolling Stone list |
The Ambassador list |
|
1 |
The Beatles |
The Beatles |
| 2 |
The Rolling Stones |
Pink Floyd |
|
3 |
U2 |
Black Sabbath |
|
4 |
Pink Floyd |
Led Zeppelin |
|
5 |
Led Zeppelin |
Deep Purple |
| 6 |
The Who |
Talking Heads |
|
7 |
Radiohead |
The Smiths |
|
8 |
Nirvana |
Genesis |
|
9 |
The Velvet Underground |
The Cure |
|
10 |
The Doors |
The Rolling Stones |
|
11 |
The Clash |
R.E.M. |
|
12 |
The Byrds |
Kraftwerk |
|
13 |
Oasis |
Dire Straits |
|
14 |
The Beach Boys |
AC/DC |
|
15 |
The Smiths |
Ramones |
|
16 |
The Police |
Joy Division |
|
17 |
R.E.M. |
The Kinks |
|
18 |
Depeche Mode |
The Band |
| 19 |
T Rex |
The Doors |
| 20 |
Queen |
The Byrds |
| 21 |
Joy Division |
Queen |
| 22 |
The Strokes |
The Beach Boys |
| 23 |
Talking Heads |
Wilco |
| 24 |
The Kinks |
The Clash |
| 25 |
Metallica |
Sex Pistols |
| 26 |
Wilco |
The Who |
| 27 |
Pearl Jam |
The Velvet Underground |
| 28 |
Guns N Roses |
CSN&Y |
| 29 |
The Band |
Cream |
| 30 |
Deep Purple |
Creedence Clearwater Revival |
| 31 |
Arcade Fire |
The Police |
| 32 |
Genesis |
Nirvana |
| 33 |
Sly Stone |
Radiohead |
| 34 |
Stone Roses |
Sonic Youth |
| 35 |
CSN&Y |
T Rex |
| 36 |
Kraftwerk |
Depeche Mode |
| 37 |
AC/DC |
Sly Stone |
|
38 |
The Cure |
Allman Brothers |
| 39 |
Black Sabbath |
Arcade Fire |
| 40 |
Sex Pistols |
Franz Ferdinand |
| 41 |
Sonic Youth |
Metallica |
| 42 |
Primal Scream |
Pearl Jam |
| 43 |
Ramones |
Primal Scream |
| 44 |
Public Enemy |
Oasis |
| 45 |
Allman Brothers |
Stone Roses |
| 46 |
Cream |
U2 |
| 47 |
Creedence Clearwater Revival |
The Strokes |
| 48 |
Red Hot Chili Peppers |
Public Enemy |
| 49 |
Dire Straits |
Red Hot Chili Peppers |
| 50 |
Franz Ferdinand |
Guns N Roses |



